Skip to main content

Tomlinson v. Jones

Opinion Date 1984-06-20
  • Court Line: Supreme Court of Texas
  • Citation: 677 S.W.2d 490
  • Subcategory: Capacity
  • Appellate Standard: Sufficiency of the evidence
  • Jury: Jury
  • Probate Court: No
  • Death Date: 1975-01-25
  • Will Age by Days: 7
Details
Contestant(s):
Father
Proponent(s):
Wife
  • Testator Male or Female: Male
  • Testator Education Summary: Unknown
  • Testator Sophistication Rating: Unknown

  • Prevailing Party in Trial Court: Proponent
  • Prevailing Party in COA: Appellee
  • Prevailing Party in Texas Supreme Court: Appellant
  • Attorney Fees Awarded in Trial Court: N/A
  • Testamentary or Contractual Capacity Case: Contractual
  • Estate Value: $ 39700.
  • Physical Condition: Pain
  • Docket Number: C-2631

Outcomes
  • Our Summary: Severe burns due to auto accident
  • Interesting Notes: Tommy's medical records, which were properly admitted into evidence at trial, paint a grim picture of a man critically injured and in great pain, at times heavily drugged, at times hallucinating, with little possibility of survival. Indeed, the discharge summary prepared by Tommy's physician after Tommy's death stated that “in spite of all [the medical] measures [drugs, respirator, etc.], the patient continued his downhill course.” We hold that this constitutes some evidence of “physical problems ... consistent with mental incapacity.”
Summaries